One Persons Journey Into Eldritch Horror

Eldritch Horror is a solid and well respected Cthulhu based board game that has been in the crowded market for over ten years.

Unlike its sibling Arkham Horror, it has been stable and controlled over its now ling shelf life. It only has one problem really, a problem we would all like to have, which is too much good content.

I decided early on to stick to the four small box expansions (SBE’s) as is often recommended to avoid the overhead, table collateral and to be honest sheer analysis paralysis of getting it all. The reality is, you cannot play it all at once, so even setting up might be a game killer if some control is not exerted.

I am also very aware that everyone will have a different take on this, but here is mine.

My Core game set consists of;

The Base Eldritch Horror game, decent enough but a little thin in areas, such as Old One and encounter cards. Looking at it now, the core set seems incomplete, but the fix is at hand.

Forsaken Lore, which was clearly designed to address all the issues above and almost a must have, adding no less than 84 more cards to the core box Big Bosses, another complete Old One up to the new standard and a solid showing of all other core card types except for new Investigators. It adds no new rules, just much needed depth.

The other part of my base set is the next published SBE Strange Remnants, which adds more good and some extras. The new Focus action gives players a useful way of dealing with inactive turns and once introduced becomes second nature. It also adds Glamour spells, unique assets, Preludes, Mystic Ruins and new Investigators.

Probably my favourite expansion, this one really rounds out the core game, makes mechanical improvements and adds flavour without shifting the parameters. If it was not for the needed additions needed for the core game in FL, it would be the must have. The BBE equivalent is Mountains of Madness.

The card count is now over 650, you have 16 Investigators, 6 Old Ones, lots of stack depth and solid replay-ability with some minor annoyances filed off.

This could be enough, certainly a good fit for occasional gamers, but spurred on by the possible demise of the game (it is hard to find at the moment and getting on a bit).

From here we have the second two SBE’s that both change things up a little. They add rules and increase difficulty considerably, while adding some variety.

Signs of Carcosa adds Hastur, a mean adversary, increases the card count across the board and introduces Talents and Impairments, which both directly effect Investigators. Impairments and Hastur share honours for “most crippling” effect in this set, so a good one for seasoned gamers on a winning streak, looking for a cure. Under the Pyramids is the equivalent BBE.

Cities in Ruin is the last of the SBE’s and the most game effecting of the SBE’s. Shudde M’ell can literally take out cities thus changing the board and (un)natural disasters become the norm. There is no direct equivalent in BBE’s but Dreamlands has a similar feeling of shifting the core parameters.

Both SoC and CiR are capable of changing the feel of the game, but neither break it or make it feel like there is added cruft for little value, mainly because their bespoke elements are directly linked to their Old Ones and neither add more board space. Many of the cards from these sets can go straight into the core game and have, but any that are linked directly to the new content provided are kept apart until needed.

This is a cool little set boasting over 1000 cards, 24 Investigators and 8 Old Ones. A solid core game with two ways of adding variety and difficulty for the jaded or overconfident gamer. Both Hastur and Shudde M’ell are genuine escalations and their rules overhead is just enough to shake things up (pun intended).

Enough, balanced and fully usable together in a variety of forms. More would just be more.

Now, to the elephant(s) in the room.

The four big box expansions (BBE’s) have never realistically been on my radar as a deliberate choice to keep it all sane and focus on other projects of similar scale.

Mountains of Madness like Forgotten Remnants adds the Focus action, more Preludes and unique Assets, 8 Investigators, 2 Old Ones and 200+ cards, but it also adds a side board (possibly the weakest) for Antarctica. It is possible to get this and the other BBE’s just for card depth, but a bit of a waste in comparison to the SBE’s.

The side boards take up space and I have felt add little for that. My golden rule for this game and others like Everdell was to avoid too many table hogging add-ons*, especially ones that force a “side game” and concentrate on maximum core game support and value.

Under the Pyramids is much the same, a little lighter in content, but tighter and more challenging. Like Carcosa, this one adds Impairments and Glamour spells, but as with the MoM and FL/SR dynamic, the small box expansion handles these changes well enough without the cost or collateral. You do get more cards (basically 1 BBE is equal to 2 SBE’s + a board, but many of the cards are tied to those boards). Like Carcosa, it is considered a tough addition, a heart breaker and not for the new player.

The Dreamlands was never really in the mix as I have mixed feelings about it and always have. The Dreamlands are as much a part of Cthulhu legend as any other element, more so probably, but I have never really had an interest in it for the RPG (even selling my gallery book for 4th edition- a mistake in hindsight). The expansion is well liked, many rating it as the best BBE and the one to get if only one is purchased, but for me it was relegated to the “only if I get the lot” category.

Mask of Nyarlethotep is for completists. Most of the content ties into elements of other expansions and is useless without them. It is basically a capstone expansion, a finisher and not great value otherwise. People criticise the large mostly empty box with no side board, but I guess if you have the lot, it adds room for all the excess bits.

I decide I might get MoM and UtP, but the only place I could find them was Noble Knight and the freight is crippling (same as the games). This does not put them out of reach, but both come in at more than I have spent on the game so far, enough to give me pause.

So I did my “thing” which was to break down all the pro’s and con’s, look at the card count, the vibe and the realistic play value of each and after creating a lovely spread sheet, I gave up in frustration.

It makes no sense to just get one, but as freight is still the problem, I cannot choose as both fit the “lots more good stuff'“ space equally, but with different strengths and weaknesses and I do question how much more good stuff I need or the boards at all?

The only expansion I can find with no crippling overseas freight is The Dreamlands, which I filed away and moved on from, but then it struck me.

I have never really seen the value in the other side boards. Why add depth to two locations in on the world map and no others? The Antarctic one is considered weakest, which makes sense as it is the oldest set and the Pyramids makes even less sense to me in a game that manages to cover the whole world in a more abstract way. If I want that level of micro detail I will role play it!

Dreamlands on the other hand is a side map of places not of this world and the weirdness and game expanding feel of that makes a lot of sense to me as a top tier revelation for the gamer who has conquered all else. It feels like the ultimate test, the lose-or-expand your mind moment of the fiction, like the last series of a TV show that has gradually expanded its scope to encompass the entire universe it operates in and more.

Being the last side-board made it is the cleverest, the most flexible (it shifts) and ties directly to the Old Ones in the box. The new elements of game play are entirely new to the game, not something any SBE’s cover, which is to say it shifts the game like Cities in Ruin, but very differently.

I realised it is the logical escalation in scope and play I might need. The card count increases to over 1200, 120 of these directly tie to the two Old Ones and the Dreamlands, including adventure cards. Some of the newer card classes like Glamour spells get a needed fleshing out. I also resonated with some of the Investigators.

I could add countless expansions like MoM and UtP etc for more of the same, there is literally no end to that were they available, but I have enough to play this game over and over without repetition. Ruins and Dreamlands allow me to actually change how the game is played without breaking it and are the finishing touches needed for the Cthulhu story loop.

Like Newleaf for Everdell, Dreamlands is the big box expansion that makes sense and does no harm.


*Everdell got the medium-big box Bellfaire for much the same reason as Forgotten Lore, because the core is better for it, several small card packs and eventually New Leaf, which seemed to be the best and most generically useful of the larger expansions and it added things that made the game better, but did not alter it’s core concepts. I did also add Mistwood, but that is all about co-op or solo play and has no board.